American Idol Update 6
And there were ten.
Lisa Tucker
She gave her rendition of Kelly Clarkson’s Because Of You. She’s one of my favourites but she’s not doing herself any justice by choosing songs like this. I think it’s a good song, but again, she seems like she’s in a shell and it doesn’t appear that she’s breaking out of it. She has got to realise that this is not going to get her out of the bottom 3, which she has been for the last couple of weeks. She will be in the bottom three again.
Ace Young
This week, he blended in a little with a forgettable performance. But he was sizzling in his on stage antics. This pin-up idol is going through to next week. No problems there.
Kellie Pickler
She’s definitely going to make a country album. She’s someone who can sing, but doesn’t have a big vocal range. So, it was also a forgettable performance. With that being said, it’s a popularity contest, and she’s here to stay.
Taylor Hicks
Taylor, Taylor, Taylor. He did a good but very average song. But I liked it. It was something different from his normal front. He was all ballad like, singing calmly and emotionally behind the microphone. It was good.
Chris Daughtry
Chris did a pretty hard rock rendition of a Creed song, which I couldn’t recognise. I couldn’t help but think that he is already a superstar rock artiste, performing one of his own tracks during a live performance. However, a lot of cover singers/bands are capable of doing the same thing. He’s all about rock. It could be soon that people start to get bored and he might loose some of his fanbase. He’ll be safely through to the next round and will not be in the bottom 3.
Katharine McPhee
Katharine (I just realised I have been spelling her name wrong)Â did a Christina. McPheever’s rendition of The Voice Within. I love McPheever, but she does not have Christina’s vocal power but McPheever did well. It was a very good song for her. No problems for her this week. Can’t wait for her performance next week.
Paris Bennett
Paris did a Beyonce. It was a superb performance. If this song was written for her, she’ll make it a top 10 hit. I wouldn’t dare to say number 1 as, she’s not quite there yet. Nonetheless, I feel she did the best this week compared to everyone else.
Elliot Yamin
Elliot did Gavin DeGraw’s I Don’t Wanna Be. Problem is, he did it completely in his own style and arrangement. Personally, I did not like it. It was like a bad cover version. But, he is a great vocalist, and this might have been his saving grace. Gavin’s song is a big big hit and voters who didn’t like Elliot’s rendition will surely not vote for him.
Bucky Covington
Bucky did a country number and it was so bland. I forgot the tune the moment he finished singing it. Being in the bottom 3 for the last couple of weeks does not help his case. He is my candidate for elimination this week.
Mandisa
Mandisa gave her rendition of Praise You. It was a good performance, but she has done a lot better before. It seemed like another week at the office for her. She seems to be stuck in a Mandisa bubble that she can’t get out of. I haven’t seen any song that she can’t sing, but I would like her to try a very slow ballad. Still in my Top 5.
So what’s the verdict. My bottom 3 is, Bucky, Lisa and ‘I don’t know’. I know it’s a cop out but, the final one in bottom 3, will be one of Kellie, Elliot or Ace. I’m swaying towards Elliot.
Update: So Lisa’s gone. Not completely surprised. I would have rather Bucky go.